Domestic Violence in Another Relationship Can Affect California Custody
A 2026 California custody opinion explains why overcoming the domestic-violence presumption in one case does not settle custody of a different child.
By Samera I. Habib · Nov 12, 2026 · 6 min read
By Samera I. Habib, CFLS | The Dadvocates
A domestic violence finding can affect a custody case even when the abuse involved a different partner. And a parent who overcame California's domestic-violence custody presumption in one proceeding cannot assume that the same result controls a case involving another child.
That is the central lesson of In re Marriage of Jessica and Sammer Z., filed August 18, 2026 and certified for publication September 8, 2026. The decision requires attention to the particular child, the relevant evidence and the findings required by Family Code section 3044.
For fathers seeking custody, the case matters in either position. A father's concern about the other parent's abusive conduct deserves a careful legal analysis. A father responding to a qualifying finding needs to understand the required showing rather than rely on a favorable order from another case. The statute applies to parents regardless of sex.
What section 3044 requires
Under Family Code section 3044, a finding that a parent seeking custody committed qualifying domestic violence within the previous five years triggers a rebuttable presumption that awarding that parent sole or joint legal or physical custody would be detrimental to the child's best interests.
The protected relationships extend beyond the other parent in the current custody dispute. The statute can reach violence against a child, the child's siblings, and other specified people with whom the parent has a relationship.
An allegation and a finding are different. The court must determine whether the statute applies; it does not simply accept an accusation as an established fact. A qualifying finding from another court can matter, and a criminal conviction is not the only way the required finding can be established. The timing and substance of the conduct require review.
Why the ruling in another case was insufficient
In Jessica and Sammer Z., the father was involved in separate proceedings with another partner concerning their daughter. That court found domestic violence and issued restraining orders. Later, it adopted the parties' stipulation that they had each rebutted the section 3044 presumption as to that child.
In the custody dispute involving Jessica and a different child, the family court treated the earlier rebuttal determination as binding. It later awarded the father joint legal and primary physical custody.
The Court of Appeal reversed the custody and visitation portions of that order. Whether the father had rebutted the presumption for one child was not the same issue as whether he had rebutted it for another. The children, relationships, and factual circumstances differed. Jessica also was not a party to the other proceeding or sufficiently represented there to be bound by its determination.
The earlier determination had been based on a stipulation, without the required statutory findings. That was another problem with treating it as an issue already litigated and conclusively decided. The opinion explains why the current custody case required its own analysis.
The appellate court did not decide that the father could never receive custody. It required the trial court to apply the correct presumption and make the necessary findings. Nor did it approve every action the mother had taken during the litigation. The custody issue had to be decided under the governing child-protection standard despite other disputes between the parents.
Rebutting the presumption requires evidence
The parent subject to section 3044 must establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the proposed custody award is in the particular child's best interests. The ordinary preference for frequent and continuing contact with both parents cannot be used to rebut the presumption, in whole or in part.
The court must also evaluate the statutory factors. They include:
- Completion of a qualifying batterer's treatment program.
- Completion of alcohol or drug counseling and parenting classes when the court determines those programs are appropriate.
- Compliance with probation or parole conditions.
- Compliance with protective or restraining orders.
- Whether further domestic violence has occurred.
- A specified court determination concerning unlawful possession or control of firearms or ammunition by a restrained person.
The court must find that these additional factors, on balance, support the statutory findings protecting the child’s health, safety and welfare. It must address each factor and state the required reasons in writing or on the record. A completion certificate can be relevant, but no single document automatically resolves the full analysis. General statements that a parent loves the child or has already completed a different custody case do not replace the required showing.
Prepare the record for this child and this proceeding
If another relationship is part of your custody dispute, provide counsel with the actual findings, protective orders, relevant judgments, and later modifications. Explain the dates of the underlying conduct, not just the date the paperwork was issued. An order that later expired or was dismissed should be reviewed with its history; do not assume the underlying findings have become irrelevant.
Then focus on the child whose custody is being decided. The child's age, relationship with each parent, exposure to violence, care needs, and proposed safeguards may differ from those of a half-sibling in another case.
For a parent seeking to rebut the presumption, maintain reliable records of treatment, compliance, and relevant changes. For a parent raising safety concerns, organize specific incidents and admissible supporting evidence. In both situations, preserve complete communications and give your lawyer the unfavorable facts as well as the favorable ones.
Custody and visitation are related but distinct. Section 3044 should not be reduced to a claim that every affected parent is permanently barred from all contact. Any proposed arrangement must be evaluated under the applicable safety rules, existing orders, and facts. Do not change the schedule unilaterally based on an article or a decision in someone else's case.
Get the legal standard right before the hearing
A custody plan needs to address the child's safety and the required law. The California Courts guide to domestic violence and custody provides a useful starting point, but overlapping cases and prior findings need individual review.
The Dadvocates represents fathers in California custody matters. Request a consultation to discuss the existing orders and evidence before relying on a result from another proceeding. If there is immediate danger, call 911.
California resources
- Jessica and Sammer Z. opinion, No. D084336, filed August 18 and published September 8, 2026.
- Family Code section 3044, the presumption, rebuttal factors and findings requirements.
- California Courts guide to domestic violence and child custody.
- California Attorney General guide to restraining orders.
This article provides general California legal information and does not determine custody rights or the effect of an order in your case. Reading it or contacting the firm does not, by itself, create an attorney-client relationship.